Pay Your Bill This information is designed to aid you in paying your bill beyond returning the invoice by mail to the insurance company or dropping it off at our office. Pay Plan Change - If you need to change your pay plan to one of the many convenient plans offered by each company, please contact us by phone at (724)735-2004 or via the Contact Us page on this website. We will be happy to discuss the options available to you. Date Due - Please take note of the day payment is being requested. Especially if there is a cancellation notice for the policy, the lapse generally occurs at 12:01am, so payment would have to be received one day prior to avoid cancellation. *Please note that each company may charge a fee for the various services listed below. Please be sure you are aware of the amount of the fee before you proceed with your payment.* Erie Insurance Online: www.erieinsurance.com, Payments Accepted from Checking or Savings Accounts By Phone: 1-800-387-1492, Payments Accepted from Debit Card, Checking Account Number, and Visa, Mastercard & Discover Credit Cards Donegal Mutual Online: www.donegalgroup.com, Payments Accepted from Checking Account or Visa & Mastercard Credit Cards By Phone: 1-800-877-0600 x 8100, Payments Accepted from Checking or Savings Account Monday through Friday, 8am - 6pm Drive Insurance from Progressive Online: www.driveinsurance.com, Payments accepted from Checking Account, or Visa, Mastercard & Discover Credit Cards By Phone: 1-800-888-7764, Payments accepted from Checking Account, or Visa, Mastercard & Discover Credit Cards Millville Mutual Online: www.millvillemutual.com, Payments accepted from Visa, Mastercard & Discover Credit Cards By Phone: 1-800-262-8495, Payments accepted from Checking Account, or Visa, Mastercard & Discover Credit Cards Foremost Billing Questions: 1-800-532-4221, Monday - Friday 7am - Midnight Saturday 7am - 5pm